Dimensions of quality explored by different scales*

Scale and study No. of levels Study design Quality of conduct Consistency of results

Canadian Task Force, 19903

4

X





US Preventive Services Task Force, 19964

5

X





AHCPR, 199211

5

X





Guyatt et al., 199512

6

X



X

Eccles et al, 199610

6

X





Hadorn et al, 199613

7

X

X



Ball et al, 199714

10

X

X

X

Liddle et al, 199715

5

X

X

X

Jovell et al, 199716

9

X

X

X

AHCPR = Agency for Health Care Policy and Research.

* An "X" indicates an area explored; a blank space indicates it was not addressed by the study.